Perfect and Imperfect Fathers


The morning is still. Glass-like reflections of the yellow sky, the purple clouds, and the distant gray mountain are perfect, not so much as a ripple in the water. Crisp, fresh air, so pure there is no description, fills my lungs. Coffee on the dock at this Adirondack lake is among my favorite things.


One of my other favorite things is to take my beautiful handmade maple acoustic guitar out to the dock and quietly pluck the strings to make a soundtrack of the morning. A single strum, followed by silence, allows me to hear the sound travel across the lake and back again in a millisecond. I choose to do it this time of year, before residents visit their lake homes, so as not to disturb them.

I took up the guitar as a teen but dropped it along the way, then found it again when my daughter was too shy to take lessons on her own, so we shared a lesson each week — and it got me hooked. I even built my own guitar, with a coach, on my birthday almost four years ago.

This was one of the gifts of fatherhood. My intent was not to take up guitar, but just to be there to reassure my daughter. Yet I ended up receiving a gift of a new passion and a new way to challenge myself and stimulate my brain.

Late to the Party

Having kids was always high on my list, but it did not happen until I was 47. I vividly recall the first blood test with high levels and my sister-in-law, a medical professional, telling us that was an indicator of multiples, and probably not just twins. I had a big smile on my face because I grew up with twin cousins and always imagined myself having twins.

The first ultrasound revealed four, three of whom were large and healthy, while one, we were told, would dissipate and not be viable.

This Should Never Happen

A couple of months into the process, a doctor sat with us and strongly suggested that there was not enough nourishment for three, which could result in one being less than healthy. Termination of one was suggested, and heavy pressure was put on us that we could not fully understand. Did they know something they weren’t telling us? It sucked the joy out of an otherwise wonderful time.

“Go home and think about it, but we need to get this done soon,” we were told. “No, we already know the answer. We’re taking what we were given and we will live with the consequences, whatever they may be.” Pressure continued. Our strong resolve protected us.

Evil Purpose

Months later we learned, quite by accident, that the pressure was not for medical reasons at all. It was because the teaching hospital that provided the in vitro would lose funding if their averages showed consistent levels of multiples more than two.

Today, three healthy and amazing 16-year-olds, each providing us with hours of entertainment, love, challenge, and laughter. What we would have missed. Which of the three would not be there for us? I cannot imagine having lived our life with these precious gifts, wondering what the third would have been like.


A wise friend, Roy Williams, taught me an important lesson many years ago. If you define who you are, what you want, what you don’t want, what you are willing to do, and what you are not willing to do, and what is non-negotiable, no matter what hits you in life, these things will give you answers without angst. Being unsure of what we were not willing to do at a time when we were weak, fragile, confused, and frightened could have allowed us to be swayed. Because we knew our non-negotiable, we did not even have to think about it.

Being There

In my early 30s, I was convinced I could happily go through life without kids, as many of my friends have. Thankfully, my “all about me” mindset changed. It may not be right for everyone, but it’s been the best gift I’ve received. Yet I know I’m merely a caretaker. I know that though they will leave the nest before long, my duties as a dad never end. My own dad, now in his 90s, is still there for me, still coaching me, still giving me brilliant ideas, and still challenging me. Same with my mom. Thank God for great genes.

Being Deliberate

I once wrote about being deliberate with the kids, and my goal this summer is to quietly work from a list of lessons that I hope to find the right moment to entrench, to help my little birds fly. We never know which summer will be our last with the kids as a family, knowing their friends take precedence, and college and life and jobs and relationships will potentially take them away.

Attracting Visits

I learned an important lesson from my own father (Happy Father’s Day, Dad), which is to make everyone want to be with you so they’ll return naturally. It started by treating us with respect when we were young, making sure we did things that were fun, and continuing those traditions. The dock I sit on is his, not mine, and because of this family home, much of our family gathers here naturally each summer, allowing us to reconnect. Though it’s a lot of work and expense, I can think of no better investment than a place that allows family to reconnect all summer every summer, or just to be there as much time as possible. I fear that when that is gone, our summer gatherings will be replaced by each of us going our separate ways. Then it will become my job to find a new way to get the kids, and hopefully grandkids one day, to look forward to our times together, wherever they may be.

Investing in the Future

There is, in my opinion, nothing more important than the relationship with our kids and their eventual families. Time invested in making them want to come back, want to spend time, is the best time we can spend. One of my saddest moments was being estranged from a family member over something I said, and one of my happiest was allowing time to pass and wounds to be healed, allowing us to be together again. Estrangement from my kids in any way would be devastating, which is why investing in them at every moment is important. That of course does not mean letting them do things that will harm themselves or their future, so correction is part of love.

Showing Up

Today, we celebrate our dads. Being a dad has helped me understand just what a great job my dad has done for me, and how he’s given me a role model for my own kids. My goal is to keep the good things, skip the things that were not productive (though I can’t think of any at the moment), and keep showing up, as he does for me still. A father’s work is never done.

Painful Memories

I don’t mean to cause pain to those who don’t have memories of a father, or whose memories are not good. I have friends who have horrible fathers who did horrific things, selfish things. I know others who did not know their dads, who grew up without a father. Though I cannot relate to what that must be like, I can say that the only thing you can do at this point is to be the parent you wish you’d had. And for those who don’t want to have kids, just know that pain provides lessons, and have confidence that you won’t repeat the mistakes of others.

Passing It On

Evil does exist in the world, but most bad dads don’t intend to be evil. Sadly, many have been the victim of a pass-it-on game pushed from father to child for generations. I recently saw a program where a famous actor looked into his ancestors, and his research indicated that the problems he had with an abusive father stemmed from his great-great-grandfather’s losing a wife at a young age, becoming an alcoholic, and beating his kids. He beat his kids, thus his son learned to beat his kids, and so on. All because of an unresolved wound three generations before.

A Football Metaphor

Years ago I took a time management course with Charles Hobbs. In the class he had a white football and a black one. He threw the white football and encouraged us to pass it on. It passed from one person to the next to the next. Then he threw the black football, but said to ground it and not pass it on. His point, of course, was to pass on the positives and not pass the negatives. I think that is true with our parents. Pass on the positive traits, ground the negative traits. Otherwise the negatives can be passed along for generations.

Choose What to Pass On

Often we don’t even recognize our own negative traits and are unwilling to listen when others try to let us know. But once we do realize them and accept that they are not productive, it’s time to ground the football. Pass the good, ground the bad. It’s never too late — even if your kids are adults, they are passing on your habits and traits, good and bad. If you realize you’ve passed something along that you regret, it’s time to apologize and encourage them not to pass that on.

Getting Unstuck Sooner

Life is full of lessons and corrections. Thankfully, we continue to evolve, learn, and make changes. Or at least, we should. Being stuck isn’t a good place to be. I know because I get stuck a lot, and then I have an “I should have had a V8” moment when I slap my head and wonder why I didn’t realize it and get unstuck sooner.

Can You Forgive?

My guess is that most fathers mean well, even though we may be clinging to some bad decision they made years ago. Forgive if you can, and move on. Not forgiving doesn’t hurt them as much as it eats away at you.

Why let anger fester inside you for a lifetime? See someone, talk to someone, try to resolve it, and even if your dad won’t apologize, you still can forgive.

I’m Grateful for You

I’d like to say something else this morning, which is that I’m grateful that you are opening these little Sunday morning moments. Sometimes I hear from people who agree, others who disagree, some who think I’ve gone too far, others who think I’ve not gone far enough. I’m not out to be an affront, or to change anyone, or even to instill my beliefs in anyone. I write because I have to get my thoughts written down, and I happened to share them with a couple of friends who encouraged me to share with others. We are all so busy, so consumed with life, with social media, with negative thoughts about politics and celebrities, I like being able to just stop and think about something I’ve not thought about before. So I hope, in some little way, this serves that purpose for you.


For me, every day I can pick up the phone and talk to mom or dad is a perfect day. A friend I once played golf with told me he would give up all his riches for just one more day with either of his parents. Yet busy lives, and the fact that it seems like our parents will always be there, tend to make us less attentive. Thus today is a reminder that I should call and visit more often.

Today let us rejoice in our fathers, their perfections and imperfections, knowing that we too are imperfect, and we too will make mistakes with our kids.


Eric Rhoads

PS: In a moment I’ll leave the dock and go over to the local college, where about 83 painters who have been with me for a week at my Publisher’s Invitational will be having breakfast, followed by my farewell announcements, followed by lots of people who got close during the week saying tearful goodbyes. Like past years, some will say goodbye and never return because of health issues or worse, others just won’t come back because of circumstances, and still others will return next year as they have for the past eight. These people are like my painting family, and I cherish them. Our next time gathering will be in the Canadian Rockies and again in Africa. It’s a hard day for me because, like a wedding, I plan it all year, then it’s here and gone in a moment. I hate goodbyes, and my kids will tell you, “Dad is crying again.” But that’s just who I am. I cherish those in my painting family, and today, when everyone checks out, I get to be with all three of my kids and my bride for a perfect Father’s Day. I hope your day is perfect as well.


  1. Jeancarlo Montjoy June 17, 2018 at 12:24 pm - Reply

    It was so profound and you spoke directly to my heart. You have given me a lot of support and thing to think about. I want too share something with you, Eric Rhoads it not alarming I would too be open as a kids I was silenced and people thought I was autistic in till I was in high school. I remember when I was in first grade and I was six year old and I did every class wrong, yesterday I was watching color in your life and thinking in the seminaries between the art that I was watching. The art was from Australia and what she said was that the all her call were hard excepted for art where she excel then, the sixth grade I was in art class and that I had fun. I also agree with max Ginsberg that in art there’s no way or very little figure art (drawing and painting)class.
    ps. I have fun in art.

  2. Terry DeFrates June 17, 2018 at 1:02 pm - Reply

    Thank you for the morning coffee. Mom passed 22 years ago, dad slipped away 10 years ago now. There is hardly a day that I don’t think of them. Mom was a stay at home mom and a sweetheart. Dad was hardly there, he preferred to work the evening shift at the factory. We had little money, but we did not know it. We grew up on the poor side of town. Life was good playing football, and baseball in the cow pasture, riding bicycles everywhere. Would not trade it for the world.
    Thank you for your morning coffee

  3. Nancie King Mertz June 17, 2018 at 1:56 pm - Reply

    Beautiful tribute to Dads everywhere! I miss my wonderful dad every day. Happy Fathers’ Day to you, Eric.

  4. Frances Pampeyan June 17, 2018 at 2:02 pm - Reply

    Dear Eric, I just love your Sunday morning letters, and this is one of my favorites. Thanks be to God that you protected your 3 babies from the poor advice of a doctor who doesn’t understand that “Children are a gift from the Lord,…”.
    I’m so glad that you can spend time with Laurie and the kids now, and with your parents. My parents are in heaven now, and so yes, enjoy each moment with them. The Lord is so good to bless us with precious parents and family.
    And I love that you cry with goodbyes. I smiled at your kids’ reaction, “Dad’s crying again.” Artists are sensitive and caring people! Have a fun summer!!!

  5. Pamela Reese June 17, 2018 at 3:02 pm - Reply

    I love your Sunday Morning musings Eric, and thoroughly enjoyed my time at the plein Air Adirondacks. Happy Farther’s Day.

  6. Glennis Peterson June 17, 2018 at 6:44 pm - Reply

    I enjoy and look forward to your Sunday coffee positive thoughts. I certainly miss my folks especially my Dad. Have a great day with newly created memories.

  7. diane June 17, 2018 at 8:59 pm - Reply

    I enjoy reading all your articles, I enjoy studying all your itinerary! So awesome, so wonderful! I will and I want to join your vacation trip overseas. Looking forward to it.

    Thanks for writing all interesting articles, cant wait to read it every one of them.

  8. chammi kaiser June 18, 2018 at 3:16 am - Reply

    I was so fortunate that my Dad who had been a very strict and somewhat abusive father but always ready to sacrifice his own needs fr his two children. As he grew older, he began to mellow and I believe he regretted his mistakes. He became a loving , wonderful Dad whom at last I was able to hug. He died a few years ago and I miss him very much. However, I am grateful to have had the Dad I always wanted for the last 20 years of his life.

  9. Stephen Burke June 18, 2018 at 2:07 pm - Reply

    Hey Captain,

    If you ever need anyone to cry with, let me know. You already know that I cry easy. You know my story. I didn’t have a father. But over my lifetime, I had a lot of guys who were a father figure for me. I have tried throughout my life to do the same and be that “World Ambassador.” Sharing my bounty and spreading kindness wherever I go and catching someone doing something right and encouraging that!

    You’re in the happy business my friend. You are a true Ambassador of the Arts. Know that your work and your writings enrich lives the world over and Anne and I are so privileged to have you in our lives. Happy Father’s Day my Friend!

    Best regards, Burkey

  10. JacquelineJuicy June 18, 2018 at 4:54 pm - Reply

    I often visit your site and have noticed that you don’t update it often.
    More frequent updates will give your site higher authority
    & rank in google. I know that writing articles takes a lot of time, but you can always help yourself with miftolo’s tools
    which will shorten the time of creating an article to a couple of seconds.

  11. Mary Montague June 19, 2018 at 5:57 am - Reply

    Thank you for sharing your thoughts every week. I can’t think of too many weeks that I haven’t found something that has stopped me and made me go back and read that paragraph again. I lost my Dad from this world 12 years ago Saturday. His lessons are always with me and his encouraging hand is still on my back.
    Looking forward to meeting you in Banaf in October.

  12. Gina Murrow June 19, 2018 at 6:11 am - Reply

    I love your Sunday Coffees. Please keep writing them!

  13. Schlesier Grace June 20, 2018 at 9:31 am - Reply

    Beautiful message Thank you once again for your compassionate Sunday Coffee. Several in my family are also sharing in your messages.
    I’m thinking today of our tearful goodbyes in Fall Color Week last year in Maine.
    I’ve made some wonderful friends from that experience and we get together to paint. Our Plein Air group that I formed after signing up for Plein Air Force at one of the PACE Conventions has grown to nearly 50 members. The 29th of this month we’re having our 2nd Museum show. Thanks Eric for giving me a little push. I would not have done it without you. So the joy of Plein Air Painting is growing and we continue to spread the word including everyone wanting to give it a try.

  14. Diane Warta June 23, 2018 at 8:00 pm - Reply

    I really enjoy your Sunday newsletter. Alway so many good things to think about.

  15. slot machines June 23, 2018 at 11:23 pm - Reply

    Have you ever considered writing an e-book or guest authoring on other websites?

    I have a blog based onn the same ideas you dioscuss and would
    really like to have you share some stories/information. I know my visitors would value your work.

    If you are even remotely interested, feel free to shoot me an email. http://twynedocs.com/index.php?title=How_Play_Online_Craps_For_Exciting

  16. Sulaine Sims June 27, 2018 at 4:37 pm - Reply

    Thank you for each and every “Sunday Coffee” emails. Each letter is full of meaning and wisdom and insight. I read them all. And I read them randomly….out of order….and on different days of the month. But each one has such depth and meaning that help me with my every day situations.. I read them like I read my morning devotional materials, Keep writing!!! You have a gift!
    Thank you, Eric!

    God bless.
    Sulaine Sims
    (I took painting classes under Charles White 2002-2005)
    What a joy and privilege to have been able to follow your career!

  17. Marietta Lippy June 28, 2018 at 2:54 pm - Reply

    Enjoyed studying this, very good stuff, thanks.

  18. Leann Colgan July 8, 2018 at 12:16 pm - Reply

    An interesting dialogue is value comment. I believe that it’s best to write more on this topic, it may not be a taboo subject however typically individuals are not sufficient to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers

  19. Awilda Grabowiecki July 18, 2018 at 5:18 am - Reply

    I got what you mean , appreciate it for putting up.Woh I am pleased to find this website through google. “I would rather be a coward than brave because people hurt you when you are brave.” by E. M. Forster.

  20. furtdso linopv July 20, 2018 at 11:31 am - Reply

    I will immediately grab your rss as I can’t find your email subscription link or e-newsletter service. Do you’ve any? Please let me know in order that I could subscribe. Thanks.

  21. click the up coming article July 20, 2018 at 11:56 am - Reply

    whoah this weblog is excellent i like reading your posts. Keep up the great paintings! You know, a lot of people are looking around for this information, you can aid them greatly.

  22. Free auto approve list 7-20-2018 July 22, 2018 at 9:09 am - Reply

    I just updated my site with a new list. I hope you all are having a great week.

Leave A Comment